Waterproof Eyeliner, 12 Colors Eye Liner Eyeshadow Pencil Eye Shadow Highlight Pen, Professional Long-Lasting Milti-Functional Cosmetics Makeup Tool (1 Set - 12pcs)

This eyeliner is amazing!!!! It goes on smooth, stays on until you take it off!! I have had no smudging or running with the colors I have used so far! For the price, these are the ones to buy if you are looking for a little bit of fun with your makeup, but don't want to pay the big bucks for name brand.

It's okI don't like it .. didn't show color very wellTwo was dried out

These works great for me because I can’t use powdered eyeshadow which always irritates my eyes. These don’t stay on without some smudging or fading but that’s ok they still fine for me.

some of the colors are not super vibrant and most are are. They go on smooth and easy! I like the product, very good price.

I will never purchase these so called waterproof eyeliners. This product is the worst set of eyeliners I have ever purchased. It is hard to apply because the tip breaks off and if I can apply it, the color only lasts for about an hour. It looks like I applied it in a circle around my eyes because it does not stay where you put it. Does not hold up and it is NOT even close to being waterproof. Total waste. They are in the trash!

Beautiful packaging, it comes in so many wonderful colors. They aren't smudge proof at all, but theu are worth the money.

I was very disappointed with this set- most of the pens seem to have very little product in them and when applied the color was not true and the appearance was quite bad in that the line was not full and the liner seemed to bleed into my eye shadow

I liked how they looked but few of them were broken. Not the plastic tubes, but the crayon itself was broke😢