Shiseido The Makeup Accentuating Cream Eyeliner 4.5g 0.15oz 2

OK. First of all, I have Asian eyes. Like the ones without double eye lids. Is this bad or good thing? That's not where I'm going. I love my eyes. BUT since I don't have double eye lids, the fat(?) from my eyelids hang over more than your double eyelids and what does this do? It touches the bottom portion of your eyes. What does that do? The eyeliner on the upper eye smudges onto bottom eye. NO MATTER WHAT I DO, that fact is unavoidable. There was the denial. Then there was the forgiveness (I love you mom!) Then the acceptance. (Yay!!) I have spent an ungodly amount of time and money on the quest for non-smudge, smudge-free, smudge-poof, your-next-best eyeliner out there known to mankind. One after the other, they broke this one eyelid-ed asian girl's heart. (I'm looking at you, Makeup Forever -_-)Then just like how love finds you when you're least expecting it, so did Shiseido. But does true love last forever? Apparently not because this product is discontinued!! How? How can you do this to me, Shiseido?? Why? I just need to know why???? Waaaaahhh-Eeeeeeeeeeeeee?

great product, will buy more from same seller thanks

Perfect!

I've tried them all: pencils, gel liners, liquid liners, cake liners. Cheap and expensive. So far this works the best and has the most staying power, without smudging. For me anyway, I will buy again.

I tested this eyeliner at the makeup counter and was amazed! I didn't think a cream eyeliner would be so easy to use. It was an intense black color (really concentrated). I didn't buy it because I wanted to see if it would last through 90 degree heat, humidity and after 5 hours it still look good. It didn't smudge like all the other cheap eyeliners I've tried. It really defined my eyes. I will say it was hard to remove, but I think I just need to use a good eye makeup remover and it wouldn't be a problem.