Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer Cookies, 10.5 oz

Wonderfully tasty cookies, but the wafers are delicate and break easily. Not for eating in bed.

I can’t keep these in the house. My husband can eat peanut butter straight from the jar but he absolutely loves these and calls them “crack wafers”. Hard to find in the local grocery stores and they make another very different cookie with the same name.

I bought these crazy good Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer Cookies, 10.5 oz. to appease our addiction to them! Why are these soooo gooood! They totally mess with my diet! My husband will eat an entire package in just one day, so I have to buy several packages at a time and then hide some from him. I have learned that when I place a Prime Pantry Order for these, I make sure NOT to order canned items, boxed items, or any heavy stuff with them. This Pantry order was just for the delicate stuff! I got 9 packages of these Nutter Butter Wafer Cookies, 6 bags of various chips and 4 bags of dried Egg Noodles, so everything arrived unsmashed that way! Conclusion: These are the Best of the Best when it comes to the Nutter Butter Cookies!

These are so very hard to find in my local grocery stores so I was happy to find them here on Amazon. Arrived quickly. Fresh and tasty. Love these

I had these delivered via prime pantry. They arrived in the form of crumbs. They were squished to the point of them being almost spreadable on toast. They are still incredibly delicious, but don't expect them to be intact when you order them.

I love these cookies and they are hard to come by; most chain stores don't carry them. I'm so glad Amazon does but apparently you can only buy them using Prime Pantry. As I have a very small family, Prime Pantry doesn't often work for me because it requires way too much volume and a whole lot of $$$. If there's another way to purchase these yummy treats, please let me know. In the meantime, enjoy!

I'm not a big fan of store bought cookies, but I have a weakness for Peanut Cremes (now known as "Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Creme Patties" and not to be confused with "Nutter Butter"s which are completely different). The decadence of eating gobs of soft peanut butter while pretending just to eat a couple cookies. I've managed on several occasions to go through a package in one sitting. One of the few treats I buy that I immediately hide from the kids.

And hazy. I remember these from childhood, I loved to peel off the thin wafer bottom and make a super cookie out of the hollow tops, filled with peanut butter. But, as I recall, they used to be larger, in two layers, whereas these are rather small, in three layers. Maybe I was smaller. But the main thing is, they're nowhere as good as I recall, I have no particular need to eat them again.