eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick for ps5 Controller, For ps4 All Model Controller - 3 Height Domed and Concave Grips Adjustable Joystick - Black

Very good quality and great fit for PS4 controller and easy to install as I have experience. This replaces my old control freaks that just fall off with any sudden movement and I wish I got this earlier.

They grip his better than the original it's really easy to use the build quality is nice nice fit and it's actually really functional to switch out the sticks depending on what game you're playing on the fly

I had no issue with installation at all here. There was a little human error. I didn't push the right thumb sticks down hard enough. It kept catching. It wasn't until I pushed it, you sort of feel it go into place when you do.Magnetic are much better but these are still up there. They don't even feel cheap even though its plastic. Worth getting.

What a great alternative to the standard Sticks , if you are like me and wanted a raised right hand stick for increased aiming / control for FPS games then this is an excellent option , one thing to note and this took me a little while to figure out but if you do not press the sticks down firmly when installing them for the first time you will put the controller back together and wonder why the sticks get stuck , as long as they are pressed down firmly enough this wont happen , would be great if these guys came out with some alternative stick attachments as the material on the top of the control stick is not that soft or grippy , overall great system.

Some previous reviews have stated that these feel and look cheap but I would disagree. Yes they are plastic but the grip is ideal and they are easily interchangeable and slot in solid.Simple to install for individuals with basic dexterity (fitted whilst carrying out dawn 2.0 remap mod - would also recommend that product) and look incredible in black.Reviews should be fair and balanced and it would be remiss of me not to mention any problems. With that being said I did get some drift on the right analog (only on CoD warzone main map but not in game) but with a little fettling the issue has disappeared.For the price it really is a solid upgrade for anyone looking to open up options on a standard PS4 controller.

The parts in the kit are really good quality, the sticks feel exactly like old dualshock. Material, fit and finish are all banging. The installation guide is super clear and easy

I liked the idea to have few options of thumbsticks after I used KontrolFreek sticks on ps4, but I realised that PS5 joystick has slightly different ergonomics and I didn't like the extended length of the sticks. So I decided to replace them completely with ExtremRate, but I found few issues with them:- although there are different height sticks, the shortest one is still taller than the original ps5 sticks. You can see on photo that I had to use 2 KF precision rings on the right stick, otherwise there was no difference with or w/o the ring- the rubbery compound seems not very sturdy, so the spikes and the outer edge on the left cup have almost gone after less than month of playing Nioh2, (see the photo), I wonder if it provides any grip after another month,- the dome sticks are too tall for me (although I have long fingers as I play piano) and I was pushing the left stick from the side, rather than from on top, which might be ok for less intense games (or for racing), but I gave up quickly.It might be me and my way of gaming, but I'd say that with such quality it's a pointless purchase, unless you play just occasionally and want longer sticks. I prefer the original ps5 sticks for their grip, length, versatility for different genres and overall quality. On PS4 joystick I couldn't go back to the original sticks after I tried KontrolFreeks, but it seems that PS5 works much better, at least for me.

My gripe is the supplied sticks, I tried to explain to Extremerate that there is not 3 heights in each stick option but they didn't get it at all. Quality is good but not great, I'm a bit wary about pressing too hard!