eXtremeRate 8 in 1 Magnetic Metal Thumbsticks for Xbox Series X/S, for Xbox One S/X & PS4 Slim/Pro Controllers with T8H Screwdrivers - Black

Despite all the text and answers that says this doesn't fit the pro controller, i bought em anyway and put them in a brand new pro controller with an extremerate shell and everything fit and works great. No more white powder bullshit from plastic and the cupped shape of the stick is also nice when playing Splatoon.All i did was push the sticks down as far as they would go and i haven't had any issues.Controller revision E, Extremerate shell (Atomic purple!)Also have the hair trigger kit on the way and the dpad shell for my joycons, this company makes good stuff. Can't wait for back buttons.

It fits perfectly with dualsense controller and it feels so smooth unlike normal plastic joysticks, the rubber feels very hard and plasticky but I guess I have to get used to it, worth the price

When I first put them on my Dualshock 4, they looked, felt, worked great, and I certainly plan on putting them on a different controller that I haven't HALL/TMR modded. The three height options all have their uses depending on the game I'm playing, though I'm not sure why the convex cap is the middle option and not the tallest, it would make more sense as the tallest in terms of grippable surface for my thumb I think.When I TMR modded my Dualshock 4, as I went to calibrate the center and range, I could not get a consistent calibration out of them until I switched to different thumbsticks, the magnets for the attachment mechanism just interfere with the position reporting of the TMR sensors, I tried to get a good calibration using these sticks but in the end I settled for the Gulikit KK style caps included in the pack with the Gulikit TMR thumbsticks I put in my controller; they're detachable, but they're a friction fit rather than a magnet fit, makes sense for the joysticks they came with.Now that they don't work with the controller I got them for anymore, I'll probably put them on one of my old Xbox One S controllers, only controllers I can think of I have left that aren't HALL or TMR modded.If you don't plan on installing those styles of thumbsticks in your controller, these are perfect, I loved the time I had with these before the thumbstick swap, and the material of the rubber tops feels plenty grippy, yet solid enough to last, while all the metal in the stems and in the base is going to be essentially indestructible in a controller, no matter how rough you are with it I don't know that it'll be easy to do more than scuff the stem against the rim, even then the rim will probably give first since it's plastic.

These thumbsticks are great. They create a very smooth motion since they are real metal, meaning they do not wear and grind against the plastic housing of a controller like plastic on plastic does. They have very smooth movement. The thumbsticks themselves are magnetic and feel nice. They don't fall out under pressure. I have replaced all of my thumbsticks on all of my controllers with these. I have yet to have any issues with them.

I bought this on a whim for my Switch Pro Controller while looking for a replacement part for my Joycons, with the idea that I could make it slightly more premium (I had wanted to use the Astro C40 TR with the Switch, but alas, it isn't compatible). The end result is... neat, on paper, but I expect to be neither more competitive nor more comfortable while playing games.Opening the controller is surprisingly easy. Despite there being twelve screws (two holding the controller grips, four holding the battery cover in place, and six holding the two halves of the controller together), they came out easily and it's not necessary to remove any ribbon cables unless you want to. Just open the controller like a book, pop the old analog sticks off, then place the new ones. Reverse the steps; easy peasy. The problem is the little issues that crop up to complicate this install.A previous reviewer recommended filing down the prongs on the rockers (the box things that you place the replacement sticks onto), which I did. I can't imagine not doing that and having these work, as even after filing those down these replacements barely operate without coming into contact with the front half of the controller. I had to go in once or twice to file some more, then leave the screws holding the controller together a little loose. That alone should be a dealbreaker, but as long as the controller doesn't creak or feel loose, I'm fine with it. Once the screws are tight, give them a full rotation counter-clockwise to resolve the sticking.But now that it's all done... eh. It's neat, to be sure, but it's not exactly game-changing. The metal sticks are glossy and make a pleasant noise when they hit the edge of their movement range, and the silicone texturing is acceptable. The excess is not precisely cut away so a small portion of it is left on some of the sticks, but it's hardly a big deal.Being able to swap out sticks on the fly with magnetic locking sounds amazing, but the included sticks aren't dramatically different. The standards are comfortable, and the double talls are exactly the same, but double the height. They're a bit awkward for my thumbs, but they could be handy for someone more acclimated. I don't see how the convex sticks are anything more than a novelty though-- the shape, combined with their silky smooth texture, means your thumbs would get better traction holding onto a stick of butter.So there you go. Some shiny analog sticks that are tedious to install comfortably and provide little benefit unless you'd like to adjust the height of them with regularity. That might appeal to you, in which case this is perfect! But for me, it's more of a parlor trick and a way to differentiate my controller from a sea of controllers when I visit friends.

These are great magnetic joy sticks it's not lose so if ypu accidentally drop your controller you won't be looking on the floor like other brands Definitely tell worth the buy

The metal version of the stick replacements don’t want to go back in place and have a weak magnet connection . I have the plastic version on a different controller and they work flawlessly.

These are awesome. The ability to magnetically switch out between the different sticks when I switch games that use the sticks differently is great! I find myself using them in 2 configurations and switching between the 2 mostly, but I really like them. They are also metal, heavy and well built. Installation is very easy if you are technically inclined, and somewhat easy with youtube videos if you don't know what you are doing. Highly recommended!