THESAEM Eco Soul Powerproof Super Slim Eyeliner - Smudge Proof Gel Eyeliner - Micro Precision Tip (2mm) - Highly Pigmented & Long-lasting Eye Makeup Glides on Smoothly, 0.1g (BR03 Teddy Brown)

Nice color and natural on my skin

I got this cos Clio ran out of stock and this seemed almost similar and affordable. Also korean made so that’s good.In terms of quality/ staying power/ waterproof, I can say it’s almost the same like Clio but I slightly prefer Clio on the finer tip as it helps when lining it as I like a more natural look.But I would definitely have no issue of buying it again.

It is great eyeliner, especially for the price. The color is good, but it does smudge.

Saw this on tik tok and decided to give it a try. My eyes water a lot so I’m always looking for something that will last. This is incredible. I smudge a dark shadow over it and it lasts all day. Highly recommend. Also great for beauty marks

Thought this was like the one I had but the one i had was slimmer and easier to make a wing eye. This one is far too thick. It is smudge resistant and long lasting but just too thick for my liking.

I ordered the THESAEM Super Slim Eyeliner in "ash black" and almost returned it immediately because both the packaging and the pencil appeared brown. However, I decided to try it out, and thankfully, it actually was the ash black I wanted, pairing nicely with my eyeshadow. The eyeliner isn't the highest quality—missing details like a freshness seal on the lid—but it does stay put all day, applies smoothly, and feels good on the skin. It's not as thin as other "super slim" eyeliners I've used, but it applies neatly without much smudging, which is a plus. While I'm more satisfied with this than my previous eyeliner, I'm still on the fence about repurchasing.

This eyeliner is decent considering its price point, but it doesn't quite match the quality of Shiseido

The color is super natural and it’s easy to apply on my lid!