Almay Gel Eyeliner, Waterproof, Fade-Proof Eye Makeup, Easy-to-Sharpen Liner Pencil, 100 All Day Grey, 0.045 Oz (Pack of 2)

I don’t usually write reviews, but I had to because I absolutely LOVE this eyeliner!! I was having an issue with other eyeliners not going on my lids at all or actually erasing the line I just drew on my eyelids. This eyeliner goes on smooth, doesn’t erase the line I’m going over (for a darker line) AND stays on all day without smudging!I’ve also had issues with other “waterproof” eyeliners rubbing off on my upper eyelid, leaving an unattractive line, but this eyeliner does not!If you like a brownish-black eyeliner, the Chestnut color goes on light, but transforms into a deeper brown with more coats. Be careful how much pressure you use because it is a gel eyeliner, which makes it a bit softer and breaks off if you’re not gentle. Another awesome feature is that it washes off easily with a regular face wash.I highly recommend this eyeliner!

According to the EWG, the ingredients in this eyeliner are safer than those found in most other eyeliners. I am no expert at applying eyeliner, so I struggle to get a straight line with this pencil. However, I like that it goes on pretty smoothly and it’s highly pigmented. Keep in mind that this pencil will need to be sharpened frequently. This eyeliner does seem to be a good value for its price.

I have purchased the Almay Gel Liner multiple times. Overall, it is a great eyeliner. It goes on well and stays on without smudging. It is also easy to remove with eye makeup remover. Also, it is EWG verified.That said, I gave it 4 stars for two reasons. First, it contains some glitter which isn’t too noticeable but the glitter is difficult to remove. Even after I take off the eyeliner, there is still some glitter at the base of my eyelashes. Second, you need to purchase the Revlon Universal pencil sharpener because the outside casing on this pencil is plastic and regular eyeliner pencil sharpeners will not work. I’ve noticed that after I’ve used it a while and sharpened it down to about half of its original length, it seems to be a bit drier and harder to get a smooth line. So I end up tossing the last half of it. Thankfully, it is not very expensive, but I do not like wasting it.

I wanted an eyeliner that’s safe to use, no unhealthy chemicals in it.I found this one on the EWG site.The price was great so I ordered it.It’s amazingly long lasting!Actually it’s the longest lasting pencil eyeliner I have ever used and I’ve tried several.

Dont waste your money, I did not like this product at all & threw it away , then went back to my usual eyeliner The tip was not thin at all it was wery thick I wanted a mechanical pencil this was not mechanical it needs aharpening so it was not for me.

If I could give this a negative rating, I would.What I got is not the product in the amazon picture. My liner crayon came in a plastic tube with no way to advance the crayon. Furthermore, when I put the cap on the back of the liner to hold it, and then took it off again, it took the end piece off with it. Now the end piece is lodged in the cab and I can't even put the cap back on! It's not possible to sharpen this liner because it would require sharpening a plastic tube, and then the very soft crayon gel would mush in the attempt.I have no idea what's going on here except that maybe this company made a mistake and produced a bunch of lemons that can't be sharpened and then is just selling them off to suckers. At $7 + some change, it's too cheap to try to get a refund, so just listen to my warning. I saw another warning of the same thing. And actually, if I DID get the kind that could be sharpened, I can't imagine how sharpening would not rip off the very soft crayon material.The only reason I got this liner over the one I love from Palladio is that this one got a EWG certification and my dark brown Palladio liner is rated at a green # 2... Still very good for toxicity, but not as good as EWG certified.Going back to my favorite Palladio eyeliner. That one can be advanced by twisting the end, it's soft and creamy, and works wonderfully well.Buyer beware on this one!

I was looking for a creamier eyeliner that goes on smooth and I wanted a color other than brown or black but something that wasn't too bright. This is perfect it's a subtle plum color goes on super smooth!! We'll be ordering different color in the same brand!

Perfect replacement for my other eyeliner pencil that had questionable ingredients. I had no idea this product was EWG certified until I was searching. The fact that it uses safe ingredients, isn’t a ridiculous price, and can also be purchased at the store, I don’t think I’ll buy any other brand again! Color is exactly as pictured, goes on smooth - so smooth that my pregnancy butterfingers accidentally swiped my mirror, fingers, cheek, and stomach on the first application - totally my fault for not being able to hold a pencil. It comes off effortlessly with my microfiber makeup remover cloth, but stays on my lid all day. I did have very slight smudging under my lower eyelashes from where I had applied it to my waterline, but not nearly as bad as my expensive brand had done. So, for an eyeliner that isn’t supposed to be waterproof, it held up exactly as it should.

It goes on smoothly, doesn’t irritate my eyes, and the colour is really nice!! I’m very happy with this purchase. Thank you!!

Hace poco vengo comprando ésta marca y me salen muy buenos, bonitos colores, dura mucho la cobertura, me parece una excelente marca y buen precio, recomiendo mucho

Buena consistencia al aplicarlo, color intenso y buen tiempo de duración.

Almay makes this gel eyeliner with low toxic ingredients. I use it to tightline. It is dark black, goes on very easily, stays on all day, doesn't irritate and washes off. It's everything I want and is my new go to eyeliner. Hope this helps.

Got this as I was looking for better rated eyeliner pencils by the EWG. I like that it glides on, but it's not retractable, so you'd have to manually sharpen it and it smudges if you have oily skin.