Maybelline New York Eyestudio Master Precise All Day Liquid Matte Eyeliner Makeup, Black, 0.06 Fluid Ounce, Pack Of 2

This is my favorite eyeliner, hands down! I love the tip. It works like a paintbrush but it's foam, so you don't have little strands of the brush making erroneous marks. I used to use the hyper easy eyeliner, and the little hairs on the brush would get caught on the tube when I put the wand back in. Then when I'd use it, it would have some hairs sticking out to the side and get extra marks on my eyelids. This tip avoids that problem but is flexible. It is just as dark as the other brush tip eyeliners, which is much darker than the pencil ones. It's also pointed at the end and makes a precision line. I like to do the cat eye look and it's perfect for that. I also like that it lasts a really long time. I've had the same one for at least 6 months and it's just now needing to be replaced. Just a heads up, though--the listing says waterproof, but it doesn't say that anywhere on the package or tube, and it sure doesn't seem waterproof. If my eyes start watering, the corners come off and smudge against my eyelids. The rest of it will be fine, but the corners always smear when wet. This seems to be more true for tears than water, though. Humidity doesn't do much, just my eyes watering or sweating. For me, the ease of application and length of use makes it worth that little annoyance. And anyway, waterproof makeup has forever plastics (pfas) in it, so I'm happy if this doesn't.

I will buy as love as available

This product had some clumps. I was able to smooth them out but defeats the ease of liquid liner. I used product until it was empty. As I continued use the clumps disappeared. I don’t know why. The clumsiness lasted about 2 weeks . Then was good.

This eyeliner works great. It was perfect for my daughter’s dance recital and easy to apply without smudging.

this has been my main eyeliner for years. It applies easily and doesn’t smudge. The problem? It’s NOT waterproof. Not even remotely. I have a problem with watery eyes at times. So I kinda need it to be a waterproof. Atleast somewhat waterproof. If you don’t mind the fact it’s not going to last, I say get it! It looks great! But if you want it to hold up and not be gone within minutes bc your eyes start to water or you had to run from your car to the building in the rain, I say find something else.