Smittybilt 9080235 Black Diamond Replacement Top with Tinted Side Windows for Jeep JK 4-Door

So, 3 stars because it's a decent product. Once it's installed it looks nice, but there are a few things that makes you realize why it's cheaper.Complaint #1: The original softtop has a sewn section you can slide the tension wire through. This one only has a flap, and the wire always pops out.Complaint 2-7: The instructions. Oh my. If 2 people followed these instructions, step by step, but one person was installing this top and the other was trying to cultivate palm trees in Siberia, you would both have an equal chance of success.Or, if you wrote out the instructions, used Google translate to translate them to Spanish, then French, then russian, then back to English, that's how I felt reading it. But worry not, they include pictures. Of course they were taken with a phone from 1982 and then xeroxed 300 times, but pictures none-the-less.I was able to succeed by watching YouTube videos of other people installing tops on random jeeps, and then piecing that knowledge together. I highly suggest this, or, hire help.It took me 5 hours to complete the job. (And yes, it was 70+ degrees out, I didn't attempt this in the cold)Not everything is a complaint: after all was said and done I have a new top, pretty windows and all for under $300. You get what you pay for, but at least in this case the material is nice and it doesn't feel or look cheap. If you're like me and gasp at $800+ for a top, go with this one, but watch plenty of YouTube and start early in the day.

The 4th top installed on my 2009 JKU Rubicon. Initially, I thought it was going to be one of those cheesy replacement top. After a few hours installing all the original hardware, this top fits like a glove. The wind noise is slightly lower than my previous top. All materials are quality materials, zippers seem to be strong and the stitching is industrial quality. What I love is that I finally do not see any seeping of water at the seals anymore! The Jeep sleeps outside and it has downpoured a few times since install. Highly recommend it as a budget replacemt top that can be treated as expendable.

I was reading some of the reviews before I ordered this top and I had mixed feelings and concerns but it fits nice and tight and had no problems with the top.

OMG!!! This was perfect for my 2007 Jeep Wrangler. I was able to install most of it without help and it looks great!! Instructions were fairly easy to follow. Thank you for making such a great product. The only down side was that the back window on the original has Velcro in the inside and while the instructions state to attach with the Velcro, it is not there.Had this product for a while now. Still impressed overall. But I would like to add that the top does not hold as tight as the old top. When it rains, it sags slightly allowing water to build up on the top. Not sure how this will affect the top in the long run. Most of the time my jeep is in the garage but not always out of the weather.

I ordered this in March and just recently tried to install it. I entered my Wrangler information to "check fit". It confirmed it fit a 2010 Wrangler JK Unlimited. Unfortunately this fits only 2007-2009 Wranglers. I did not see that in the description and now stuck with it. It's a quality product, just not aligned with the "check fit" database.

Soft top arrived today, on time, unpacked and seemed of high quality. Spent three hours taking off my old torn top, and installing this new top. Only to be putting the very last back driver side window, and when I went to zip the window up, before I even attached the window, the zipper on the soft top broke off. Now I have to try and find someone around town who can fix this zipper so I can utilize the whole top, rather than erase my entire day of work, return the product, not have a top until they sent a new one, aNd then spend several more hours installing the second one. Very disappointing as 400 dollars is a lot of money, and I only have one day off a week, and spent my day off to not be able to complete a simple task because of a lack of quality

Pretty easy to install. Follow directions! This will save so much time! So far I haven’t seen a single leak. Windows are soooo easy to unzip!

Your browser does not support HTML5 video.  Picture one passenger side, the top doesn’t stay hooked in, when driving the air pushes it out the rest of the way and it flaps in the wind. Picture 2 driver side, not sure why along the edge the fabric is pulling apart and turning white. Picture 3 seems like the fabric has shrunk and causing a space on the top like it’s pulling it. I only had the vehicle for 10 months. Please let me know what I can do to fix these problems. Thank you Nick Cabuno

Roof was laid out in the sun on a lawn for a bit to soften. A blanket over the hood is a good idea top prevent scratches also. Installation by two took about 1.5 hours at most.

Looks great have to wait until Spring