MARCELLE2-in-1 Retractable Eyeliner, Azurite, Waterproof, Easy-To-Smudge, Smokey Eye, Long-Lasting 12h, Fragrance-Free, Hypoallergenic, Cruelty-Free, 0.31 g

Love this eyeliner, perfect color, it’s smooth doesn’t pull. Truly waterproof doesn’t run or smear. I have very sensitive eyes and this doesn’t bother mine

Not hypoallergenic. Still looking for a new product. Lines eyes very well. Color is great. Then my eyes turn red and start tearing.

Best eyeliner I've found & I'm older with new eye sensitivities - good time...No allergic reaction, stays on for hours & glides on beautifully! Way better than Almay which I used for years. This is well made!

Best waterproof liner I’ve tried and I think I tried every waterproof eyeliner on the market. Stayed put all day. Luv the charcoal grey as it doesn’t give you that over made up look. At some point I’ll be returning to purchase the brown shade.

Was not waterproof as many others mentioned. Ended up with brown patches under my eyes. My skin is not oily.

I HIGHLY recommend this product because it doesn't have any harmful or carcinogenic chemicals in it. Plus if you're super sensitive like I am then this is definitely a product for you.

Great eyeliner! Easy to apply and stays on all day. I will be purchasing again!!

Lovely soft brown color....easy to apply and stays on well.

It says it is waterproof and it is definitely not waterproof. But I'm glad because I was looking for an eyeliner that is easy to take off and this eyeliner comes off in one wipe of makeup remover! It is also very fine which is good for precision and it is a nice colour.

I ordered this eye-liner pencil as I have very sensitive eyes. I find that my eyes usually water when I wear eye makeup. I found that this eye-liner is very soft and smooth and easy to apply. There is no tugging on the eye lids at all and it is non-irritating. I ordered the brown and really like the colour with my hazel eyes. I would recommend this eyeliner and will be purchasing it again.

I've been using this for about a week and am really happy so far. The copper colour goes well with blue eyes. The product doesn't really smudge throughout the day, as I had noticed my previous liner doing. I like the sponge tip but am still getting used to it!

Brûle quand appliquer sur mes yeux. J'achète pourtant leurs produits depuis une dizaine d'années pour mes yeux sensibles et je n'ai jamais eu ce problème. Ne pas acheter sur amazon!

Love this eyeliner...no smudge and glides on easily