Jolie Cosmetics Indelible Eyes Waterproof Automatic Pencil Eye Liner (Brownstone)

This is the best natural eyeliner that I have found so far. It glides easily on, and the pencil is easy to control. The only reason I did not give 5 stars is that it smudges a bit too easily.

My wife liked it. Arrived on time. Only draw back is it said automatic not sure what they meant by and no instructions? If you pull out extra, you cant roll it back

My personal experience with Jolie Cosmetics Indelible Eyes Waterproof Automatic Pencil Eye Liner is that it is easy to apply without some of the "tugging" or "dragging" I have had with other brands, and it lasts all day. I have it in the Brownstone and Pitch Black colors. This eyeliner out-performs all the other waterproof liners I have tried by other major brands over the last few years.

I love this eyeliner, it goes on very smoothly (more so than most pencils) but stays on throughout the day. I usually only apply once, but sometimes if I'm going out I will apply again in the evening. It has the vivid color of a liquid but the softness of pencil. And even though it's waterproof, I don't need to use eye makeup remover, I only use water and a Norwex cloth and it comes off easily.

Goes on easily but it dosen't always stay put.

I used to use something else but this popped up as a suggestion. I tried it and I now just use this eyeliner. I live in a hot and humid climate and I have oily skin so I occasionally have to reapply, but most days it stays put. It's not sticky or thick and smudges nicely. I wish they had more colors!

Love this eyeliner, easy to put on and looks amazing

I love this eye liner it doesn’t smudge it’s waterproof the color is perfect I would highly recommend it