e.l.f. Cookies 'N Dreams Lip Gloss, Limited Edition Non-sticky, Creamy Lip Gloss With A Shiny Finish, Nourishing & Hydrating Formula, Cream Come True

Its a nice sheer black, not extremely noticeable but pairs with any lipstick. It smells greattt and is good for the value! A little bit sticky but not bad at all.

It leaves you with a subtle shine that is perfect for everyday use. Its texture is very moisturizing and has beautiful shine. I highly recommend it for people who don't like to wear a lot of makeup

As my title states, this doesn't pack a lot of punch but it adds a little something extra when applied over top of lipstick. It really brings out cool tones while darkening just a little. I love its sparkle and sheen! It is a bit sticky but not uncomfortably so. I got this to try as a dupe for CP's Jacob lip oil and it's close enough that I don't feel I need the other one anymore. This is my go-to gloss currently, really like it!

Nice! Gift for granddaughter

I saw someone suggest this in the comments of a video about Fenty's lip gloss in shade "Major Flex" (silver) and had to try it out. It's not a dupe by any means, but is another dark/gray shimmery lip gloss. The commenter I saw recommended adding this over the top of other lip products to make the color cooler, and as someone with very cool toned skin and coloring, I was eager to try it out. I like the color on me - it goes one sheer for anyone who is freaked out at the idea of black lip gloss! However, the formula is pretty sticky and feels rather tacky, like it's sticking together whenever I open my lips. It feels like it might be a more pleasant texture if I could put more on and have a heavier layer of product on my lips, but not much comes out on the applicator. The head of the applicator is also very flexible, so it's difficult to apply with precision because it bends when any pressure is applied. I wouldn't purchase again, but for a couple of bucks, I'm not too upset about it.

This product reminds me of the vanilla lip smackers from back in the day it smells and tastes good lol. The smell is amazing and the color is perfect. It’s not too sticky either so good job on this one. Lip smacker was stupid to discontinue that vanilla one.

It's lipgloss, so it'll be a little sticky when put on, but the formula is very conditioning. I like to apply it over a nude lip pencil to give it that vampy look. Looks AMAZING over red. Great over a bare lip too. It's honestly just a great product. Plus, it smells like the cookie part of an Oreo!

I love this! The color is so cool. It’s not an opaque black, I would recommend looking up swatches or videos on black lipgloss if you are unfamiliar with the shade. An excellent dupe for the Isamaya or Mac Cosmetics version. At 4 bucks it’s truly a steal. My only complaint is that it is a little thick, a little difficult to spread on the lips!