SUGAR CosmeticsEye Told You So! Smudgeproof Eyeliner01 Black Swan (Black) intensely pigmented liquid, Sweat proof, Moisture resistant, Long lasting, Matte finish

Best liquid eyeliner, ever! I've been wearing liquid liner for 20 yrs and this stuff is amazing. It doesn't smudge or flake off. The wand is easy to apply.Just ordered my second tube.REPEAT CUSTOMER!

Love this eyeliner. It goes on smooth and stays on all day long and it is easy to take off at the end of the day. If you are a person that rubs your eyes a lot it will rub off eventually as you continue to rub your eyes.

Terrible product: the texture is watery and transparent. It is impossible to apply on the eye shadow: this eyeliner erases the shadows, but does not apply a liner color.The color is green, but not the declared shade: the color of the garter is more yellow.The tube was smeared with some old-fashioned makeup. And it is impossible to return it.

Smooth application. High Pigment. Great product.

Looove it Matt finish

Goes on quite nicely, but very messy when removing, black flakes get all over my face when I take this stuff off with makeup wipes.Edit: after more than a couple of uses, the quality becomes terrible. Super smudgey and hard to control. Waste of money :/

I am a fan of this eye liner

Didn't like the colour and is 2019 manufactured only one year shelf life left

Bad product was totally dried inside waste of money

If you do a lot of frequent winged eyeliner looks, then this might not be ideal. If you're looking for an eyeliner to help you do that, opt for a pen eyeliner. The product itself is quite good. It's richly pigmented and lasts all day long-the trick is to not touch your eyes. If you touch or rub your eyes, then it'll flake right off (if you have oily skin/lids.) It's cruelty free and that's a big plus for me. I have sensitive eyes and I wear contact lenses and no allergic reactions- no issues at all. So don't think twice! Go ahead and buy.

It's nice and last longer. Liked it.