Assault On Precinct 13 [DVD]

I have the original 'Assault on Precinct 13' (1976) film on DVD and this 2005 remake. There is often a temptation to compare remakes with originals and decide which is the better of the two, but I really struggle to do that with AOP13, as they're two very different films, notwithstanding the fact they're based on the same premise of a police station coming under attack.In the 1976 version which is a much more brooding and sinister film, the criminal gang's motivation for attacking the police station, is to avenge the deaths of several gang members at the hands of the LAPD, and to reach someone they're hunting, who seeks refuge inside the station. Whereas the 2005 version revolves around corrupt police officers attacking the police station, to try and kill a cop killer (played by Laurence Fishburne) who is being held prisoner inside, as letting him live (and everyone else inside the station who are witnesses), would reveal their corruption. In both films the prisoners team up with the cops to try and survive the onslaught.Personally I love both versions of AOP13 and highly recommend watching them both. Between the two, I would say the 2005 version has some better action scenes, but they are both great films in their own right, and have compelling plots.

A great film

Good movie, story line. Lots of action

nothng

Having seen this on Sky television for the first time I thought it was a very gripping film. I knew straight away I had to add this to my film collection. I particularly like the extra twist in the story in how they manage to hold off the assualt on the precinct, as well as who those people are who attack it. I won't spoil the fun by revealing this but thought I would mention this as it adds to the film's high rating which I have given it. I think Ethan Hawke plays a very good lead role and is very believable as the main hero of the story, despite his young looks. The film keeps you guessing where the next attack will come from. All those fans of guns and modern weapons will enjoy those used in the film too. I particularly like the fact that the assault takes part during a blizzard too, which adds to the desperation of the attempts to break out from it. A must see film, particularly for those who enjoy films like Die Hard, Heat and Collateral. A highly recommended buy.

injoyed it very much

Lots of surprises - you don't know who to trust! A great ensemble cast, with a mix of A-list and new faces, and most given enough backstory and dialogue to play a real part in keeping you engaged and the tension high. The action cinematography is good too - not too frenetic, just enough to give a sense of disorientation and uncertainty in fight scenes. Very nicely done.

I think this is a good film.