stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip Lasting Satin Finish, Smudge-Proof & Transfer-Resistant

Have used this particular product for years as it glides on nicely, love the small tip applicator and it stays on all day without smudging. Causes no eye irritation and is not dry so as not to flake off throughout the day. Love the colors available and reorder again and again.

The color matches what was advertised and it’s so easy to apply. It glides on without having to press down forcefully on my eyelid and lasts all day without smudging.

This is the perfect eyeliner! It's worth the money! Goes on silky smooth and stays on all day. No touch ups needed! Doesn't run and one application .

I was looking for a good eyeliner to replace the Tarte maneater liquid liner that has been discontinued. This one almost fit the bill. I really like it, but not quite perfect for me. It somehow seems dryer even though it goes on wet. I have to shake the pen slightly before doing my 2nd eye. It stays all day, but does become slightly flaky by night. Not that I recommend sleeping in makeup, but if you do, it will be at least half flake off by morning. My maneater liner could stay put for days. This has traditional applicator vs the brush which I suspect is what makes it less wet on application. Pros: goes on easy, stays all day. Dries quickly after application, great black matte fine line color. Fantastic for fine line strokes Cons: formula or applicator a little dry, slightly flakes by evening. When applying need to gently shake to get applicator wet enough for broader strokes on one pass, or go over line a couple times.

This is seriously the best liquid liner on the market. It lasts long and doesn’t budge throughout the day. It glides on easily, and is very bold looking. Easy to remove with makeup remover, but will stay put all day.

Best eyeliner! I think it’s underrated. Perfect cat eye and thin

One of these used to last several months. Now after a few weeks it runs out. I see others commenting about it. Not sure what happened but it is not worth the price. I am not purchasing this every month so looking for a new brand. It is easy to apply and stays on well.

This eyeliner makes a precise line and stays on relatively well, but smudges as the day goes on. It is easily applied, and removes well when the day is through with facial cleanser. The color stays true during wear. For the difference in cost to what I previously used, I really wouldn’t be inclined to purchase Stila again.