It Cosmetics No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner (1.20G, Super Black)

Good stuff, doesn’t budge & lasts well. I will definitely buy again.

I have been a huge fan of It Cosmetics for the No Tug Gel Eyeliner and eyebrow pencil for several years and have referred the product to others. They recently switched to the Super Hero line. It is a Super Disappointment! It is no longer shelf-sharpening. The first time I applied it, it broke off. I bought a sharpener and sharpened it (which is a pain). The no-tug is a lie. It tugged my skin and just clumped up my eyelashes. My pic isn’t the best, but you can get the idea. This product is pricey and not usable! I email It cosmetics and inquired about the previous product and if it was available. They did respond quickly and indicated it was discontinued. I have made a switch to another product line and it is similar to the product I used to love.

The IT Cosmetics Waterproof Gel Liner was a game changer, I finally had found the perfect eyeliner. Not realizing that they had changed it, I ordered the Superhero. I am completely disgusted. I used it this morning for the first time and it stung my eyes so bad I had to take it off and start again. The product itself is so soft that I had to "sharpen" it to use it because it just melted with the first application. The second application found it thick and clumpy. If I could return this, I absolutely would. I will be using cheap stuff to fill in until I can find a replacement. Consider yourself warned should you decide to try it!

Favorite eye liner of all time ! Smooth stays on ! Does not make eyes water . Have to sharpen pencil often ! I feel like I waste product . Pricey ! But awesome eye liner pretty black sheen . I like the roll up one better !

I used to love this product. I was a loyal customer for the last 2 years and purchased the product via AMAZON for the last year. The quality of this product has changed for the worst. I thought it was me or just a manufacturers mistake. So, I purchased 4 pencils within the last 2 months and all 4 pencils were bad. The all had the same issues; a very small tip and when that disappeared it was finished. There was no product in the body of the pencil. You could turn the tip forever but no product would appear, it was finished! I never looked for a sharpener cause I never had enough product to sharpen! I'm done. I've moved on to a better company and I suggest you do the same! TRM