Natural Farm Odor-Free Collagen Chews, (12-Inch, 12-Pack), Long Lasting Bully Sticks & Rawhide Alternative Dog Treats, 95% Collagen, High Protein Best Dental Dog Treats – Medium & Large Dogs

I don't know why these have a 4.2 rating because they're great. My puppy adores them, I love the long 12" size because I can use it to play with my puppy and not get nipped. They're not smelly at all, but I actually wouldn't care so much if they were. They are lasting forever. I am buying a holer for them that I hope works as a nice little handle

Our border collie loves these!!!! Great valley and good size for price. It is great for a dog that needs a thick bully stick to chew. These take her awhile and keep her occupied.

These seem to last longer for my giant chew-hound than other brands, sometimes even 3-4 days. They're thick and sturdy, a great length for my dog, too. There's no smell or staining when he chews them, the only time I smell it is when I open the bag which reseals for freshness.

My small dogs really like the chews and they last a long time. The only problem is I wanted small 6 inch chews but in the bag there are really thick ones meant more for a medium size dog. It would be nice if they were more consistent..third bag was perfect;)

Let me preface this by saying I have used this product as a dog trainer for over 3 years. Tested on over 15 different large and medium sized breeds. They work.Is there a smell? Maybe. Guess what? They're made from animal products. They are going to have an odor. No matter what brand you buy, regardless if it says "no odor," there will ALWAYS BE AN ODOR. Get past that and accept it. That's not a reason to give a bad review.Dogs LOVE IT. And it will take them quite some time to get through one. I'm talking at least 20 minutes, which is a LONG TIME to keep a dog occupied. I saw one reviewer complain that it "only lasted an hour" lmao bless your heart.If it doesn't last at least 15-20 minutes you have a maniac of a dog or you need a bigger size.If it makes your dog sick, that's between your dog's digestive system and the bully stick. I've never seen it make any dog sick in my personal experience. Every dog reacts differently to different food sources. Again, not a reason to give a bad review.I will continue buying these bully sticks for my dogs. Sometimes you get some irregular sizes, but that's just what happens sometimes. These colleges sticks aren't manufactured by hand.5/5!

My puppy loves these and they are healthier than bully sticks and also have no foul odor

I have these on reorder because my dog loved them and gets one a day. I initially liked these because there was low odor compared to bully sticks with the same chew time and convenience at a lower price.Lately the quality has been hit or miss. As you can see, one or both of the ends can 'bloom' and become brittle. The dog loses interest once this happens.The size is also getting more inconsistent. Some are too thick for our medium holder (I use our yak cheese holder for those). I had to get a small holder to accommodate the thin sticks, which there seems to be more of now. We've had a couple sticks over multiple bags that were a little too thin for the small holder. Usually you can find a spot in the middle of the stick that secures in the holder; now at the risk of a double end bloom/frustrating release when it's done.I also had one bag over the summer that STANK! worse than bully sticks. Though the dog still ate them.

These are grat. My bulldog loves them and they last longer than many other sticks I have tried. Highly recommend.