15PCS Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set, Eye Shadow Pencil, Pearl & Matte Metallic Glitter Eyeliner for Women, Eye & Lip Liner, Professional Eye Makeup Set

I love this eyeliners !! They are smooth and easy to apply. They don’t make my eyes feel dry as well. I really liked them!

Creamy formula is decently pigmented. It can smudge, but doesn't easily migrate, you do have to rub it firmly to move it. Mine are labeled as eye and lip pencils, and the formula does work as either. I even experimented with using a shade all over the eyelid as a shadow, which worked OK, and I really liked the dramatic blue color. These are fun to play around with and well worth the price I paid for them. They are a great way to experiment with bold colors to see what you like.

Why did you pick this product vs others?: The price is very reasonable and it’s a smooth application process. I love the variety of colors. it doesn’t irritate my eyes. But for the length of the pencils, I thought I would have gotten more than just the existing tip on each pencil. Just like a previous review commented, you can’t sharpen them, or twist for a little more product after several applications with the current point. As per smudging, I sometimes had the eyeliner I applied on my eyelids smudge in the course of the day and I looked like I had applied eyeshadow, which I hadn’t. It didn’t look horrible, but I wasn’t expecting it to look that way. The only reason I would probably buy again is because of the price and colors. Quality is not the greatest, but that’s what the low price indicates.

So in love with the colors

Very pigmented and easy to use. Love it so many colors to chose.

Love the colors, some colors don't show great. Not waterproof but I still like them

beautiful creamy liners. Pigmented. The box says they are twist up and retractable and no need to sharpen. That is incorrect. The do not twist up. Other than that they are just as described. You will need to sharpen them. Once you remove from box they do not fit back in the box neatly.

The twist ups break way too easy and it isn’t long lasting, the colors are great and there, but I hate applying it and I can’t push it up.

Excellent quality