Sulily 12 Colors Matte Lip Liner/Lipstick Set,One Step Lips Makeup Kit,Velvet Nude Collection Waterproof Long Wear Lip Gloss, Lip Liner for Women To Create The Perfect Matte Lip Look

I loved everything about these lip, pencils!I would recommend these to anyone because you have so many choices and they are great pencils for an amazing price!!!!! I love that there are such natural colors as well as vibrant colors. They go on easily and they stay on for quite a long time during the day.

I absolutely loved these liners! They stay on for a long time, they are pigmented and the shade range was just what I was looking for. They also don't dry my lips

Love these lip liners

I do love these! I don’t agree with the extra waterproof statement on the box but they work very well, go on smooth, don’t dry out my lips and pretty colors. I do have to touch up a lot though so 3 star but definitely worth value and how much you get I think

Terrific colors. Goes on smoothly and actually lasts! Hidden gem at an amazing price.

Love these!

Not waterproof, will stick to your cup, basically skinny cheap lipstick

Nice colors